Online Orders Ship Fresh Every Tuesday
Be sure to place your order by Monday at 10 AM to receive your shipment that week.

Stoltzfus Cheese Gift Boxes Make the Perfect Gift for Your Loved One

Our delicious, wholesome, hometown farm goods are the best way to bring the Central New York love to the hearts and mouths of your friends and family this holiday season. We’ve put together a special collection of select cheeses and meats from our family farm for the holiday gift boxes.

These gift boxes are the perfect gift for your neighbor, friend, or family member. You can ship them to your home, pick them up at our Stoltzfus Family Dairy, or ship them straight to your loved one's mailbox.

Why order a gift box instead of assembling your own? These gift boxes are carefully and neatly packed and include Christmas colored filling for a festive look. The outside of the boxes also have a Christmas look, so you can give them as is or you can add your own touch by wrapping ithem with your favorite Christmas wrapping paper. Add a large Christmas bow to top it off.

Choose between our Large Holiday Gift Box, Small Holiday Gift Box, and Yogurt Gift Box. These delicious selections consist of a variety of products including our farmstead cheeses, cheese curds, cheese wheel, yogurt, and Stoltzfus Meats beef sticks.

Our standard gift box options are outlined below but can be customized to all of you or your family and friend's personal favorites at your request.

Large Holiday Gift Box

 Each of the Large Holiday Gift Boxes is jam-packed with the best meat and dairy products from here to Lake Erie. In the box are 3 Farmstead Cheese Wedges: tomato and basil, natural, and sour cream and onion flavors. There are also 2 containers of our mouth-watering cheese curds, the buffalo hot wing, and natural flavors. In the large boxes, you get a pack of Stoltzfus Meats Sweet Bologna Snack Sticks.

Small Holiday Gift Box

 Each of the Small Holiday Gift Boxes includes a 2 lb wheel of Stoltzfus Dairy Natural Farmstead Cheese and a pack of Stoltzfus Meats Sweet Bologna Snack Sticks.

Yogurt Gift Box (only available for in-store pick up)

Each Yogurt Gift Box includes 12 High Protein Yogurts in the following flavors: Strawberry, Peach, Blueberry, Maple, Raspberry, Black Cherry, Apple-Cinnamon & Pineapple Banana! Also included is a container of our cheese curds in Natural Flavor! NOT AVAILABLE FOR ONLINE ORDERING – In Store Pick Up Only

You can also pick up any of our gift boxes at our Stoltzfus Family Dairy store in Vernon Center, New York (6300 Skinner Road, Vernon Center, NY 13477) instead of having them shipped. 

To receive customizations on any of these gift box orders, enter specific customization instructions underneath your cart when ready to check out. Customization instructions should be placed within the box underneath "Special Instructions for Seller".

Special for the month of December: We will ship your gift boxes to you for free when you place an order of at least $50. Simply enter the code "SHIP50" at checkout! 

Happy shopping!


  • Dec 10, 2021
  • Category: News
  • Comments: 0
Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

Shopping Cart
No products in the cart.